rentals

Discover Premier Rental Properties in Sebring

Explore Our Rental Property Listings

Keystone Realty offers a diverse portfolio of rental properties in prime locations, providing tenants with a range of options to suit their lifestyle and budget. From cozy apartments and townhouses to spacious single-family homes and luxury condos, our rental listings are meticulously curated to meet the diverse needs of our clients. With a focus on exceptional service and attention to detail, our team at Keystone Realty is dedicated to helping tenants find the perfect rental property that feels like home. Whether you're looking for a short-term lease or a long-term rental, trust Keystone Realty to make your renting experience seamless and stress-free.

Call Us

Years of Expertise

We're dedicated to providing top-notch assistance for clients with a diverse array of real estate needs. Whether it's listing residential homes, expansive land parcels, or commercial properties, we've got you covered. With our expertise we expertly manage a portfolio of over 30 rental properties, ensuring both landlords and tenants experience seamless transactions and peace of mind. Michelle Hutto, with 27 years as a broker and 35 years in construction, owns Keystone Realty, offering unparalleled expertise in both industries.

Contact Us

Your Comprehensive Real Estate Partner

At Keystone Realty, we take pride in the diversity and expertise of our team, ensuring that no matter your real estate needs, we have the right agent ready to assist you. We've forged invaluable relationships with a range of trusted affiliates, including mortgage brokers, lenders, home inspectors, subcontractors, cleaning services, and lawn management professionals. This network allows us to offer comprehensive support throughout your real estate journey, ensuring that every aspect is handled with precision and care.

Get Started

The Dream Team

Our team of experienced Realtors is dedicated to delivering exceptional service and guiding you through every step of your real estate journey.


  • Michelle Hutto, with 27 years as a broker and 35 years in construction, owns Keystone Realty, offering unparalleled expertise in both industries.
  • Cindy Wise embodies the dual roles of a devoted full-time Nana and a top-producing agent, channeling her unwavering dedication to both. She is always wholeheartedly committed to helping them achieve their dreams of finding the perfect home.
  • Sue Eisenhart brings a specialized focus to the vibrant 55+ community at Lily Lake Golf & RV Resort, where she lives, works, and plays golf when she can fit it into her busy schedule.
  • Michael Hutto's diverse roles as a business owner, city councilman, and sales associate reflect his unwavering dedication to serving his community with excellence, especially dealing with tracts of land, re-zoning issues, and more.
  • Meghan Hadden is instrumental with our social media and real estate listing posts. We enjoy her expert and creative abilities in keeping our clients information fresh and readily available to customers that utilize digital marketing.
Contact Us

Proudly Serving Central Florida

New ParagraphCovering Central Florida's Most Desirable Locations: Frostproof, Avon Park, Lake Wales, Sebring, Cypress Gardens, Bartow, Winter Haven, and Haines City. Our comprehensive services extend across these vibrant communities, providing expert real estate assistance tailored to each unique area's market dynamics and client needs. Whether buying, selling, or renting, trust our dedicated team to deliver unparalleled support and guidance throughout your real estate journey in Central Florida.

Call Us

Exploring Residential Real Estate

Discover your dream home in Central Florida's vibrant communities. From cozy suburban neighborhoods to luxurious waterfront properties, our team is here to guide you every step of the way. With a keen understanding of local market trends and a commitment to personalized service, we'll help you find the perfect place to call home in the heart of Central Florida.

Lets Talk

Property Management Solutions

Entrust your properties to our dedicated team for seamless management services in Central Florida. From tenant acquisition and lease administration to maintenance and financial reporting, we handle it all with professionalism and efficiency. With a focus on maximizing returns and preserving property value, let us simplify your investment journey and ensure peace of mind every step of the way.

Get Started

Unlocking Opportunities in Commercial Real Estate

From bustling urban centers to serene suburban landscapes, Central Florida offers diverse investment prospects. Whether you're seeking prime retail spaces, office buildings, or industrial facilities, our expertise and local insights ensure informed decisions. With a growing economy and strategic location, now is the time to capitalize on the potential of Central Florida's commercial real estate market.

Let Us Help You

Find Your Perfect Rental

Explore a wide range of rental properties tailored to your lifestyle and preferences. Whether you're seeking a cozy apartment, a spacious townhouse, or a luxurious waterfront villa, our extensive listings have something for everyone. With attentive customer service and streamlined rental processes, let us help you find the ideal rental property that suits your needs and exceeds your expectations.

Contact Us

Contact Keystone Realty Today!

Keystone Realty

245 S Scenic Hwy

Frostproof, FL, 33843


Office: 

863-635-0030
Michelle Hutto Broker/Owner, Realtor Cell:  863-999-3678
Cindy Wise Sales Associate, Realtor Cell:  863-528-0366
Sue Eisenhart Sales Associate, Realtor Cell:   248-431-1441248-431-1441
Michael Hutto Sales Associate, Realtor Cell:   863-999-3678863-999-3678

Contact Us

Why is Keystone Realty So Popular?

When it comes to finding the perfect rentals property, look no further than Keystone Realty. Our extensive portfolio of  rentals properties offers a diverse range of options to suit every tenant's needs and preferences. With a focus on exceptional service and attention to detail, Keystone Realty's rentals listings are meticulously curated to provide tenants with a seamless and stress-free renting experience. Whether you're looking for a cozy apartment, a spacious townhouse, or a luxury condo, our rentals properties are designed to meet your lifestyle and budget requirements. Keystone Realty's rentals are the ideal choice for tenants seeking quality, convenience, and comfort in their rental experience.

Call Now

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What types of real estate services do you offer?

    We offer the following real estate services:

    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Residential Real Estate
    • Property Management
    • Rentals
  • What is the best way to contact you?

    You can call us at 863-635-0030 or email us at michellehutto1136@gmail.com. You can also use the form on our Contact Us page.

Rentals in Sebring, FL

Share by: